Thousands of College Programs Fail Federal Earnings Test: What It Means for Students
For students, parents, and educators navigating the complex landscape of higher education, the return on investment for college programs is a paramount concern. A recent whitepaper, The Earnings Test, from Validated Insights, sheds light on a significant issue: thousands of college programs across the United States currently fail a federal earnings test designed to ensure graduates earn more than a high school graduate in the same state. This development, based on an analysis of the Department of Education's (ED) preview data, has substantial implications for program viability, student borrowing, and future career prospects.
According to Validated Insights, 2,880 programs out of nearly 50,000 evaluated with sufficient data are at risk, enrolling 643,852 students, with 308,207 of these students borrowing federal loans for their education. The whitepaper not only identifies these at-risk programs but also proposes concrete strategies for institutions to enhance graduate earning outcomes and mitigate the risk of failing ED's earnings standards.
Understanding the Federal Earnings Test and Its Impact
The federal earnings test is a critical accountability measure designed to protect students and taxpayers by ensuring that postsecondary programs prepare graduates for gainful employment that justifies the cost of their education. Programs that consistently fail this test could face sanctions, including the loss of eligibility for federal student aid programs, which would severely impact their ability to enroll students.
Validated Insights' analysis indicates that the Department of Education's first determination based on this test is expected in early 2027, evaluating students who completed programs in 2021. Programs could potentially lose access to federal loans as early as the 2028-2029 academic year if they fail the test twice within a three-year period. This timeline underscores the urgency for institutions to review their programs and implement improvements.
The whitepaper highlights specific trends in programs at risk. Certificate programs, for instance, face the highest risk, with 29% failing the test, compared to significantly lower rates for associate, master's, and bachelor's degrees. Many of these at-risk certificate programs are in health fields like medical and dental assisting. Other identified areas include mental-health counseling, early-childhood associate degrees, human development associate degrees, and certain fine arts, drama, and music master's programs. However, the report also offers reassurance, noting that most of higher education is not at risk, with fields like nursing, medicine, law, engineering, and computing showing very low failure rates.
Strategies for Improving Program Outcomes
Brady Colby, Head of Market Research at Validated Insights, emphasizes that institutions are not powerless in addressing these challenges. The whitepaper identifies seven key levers that colleges can engage to improve graduates' earning outcomes and reduce the risk of failing the earnings test. These strategies are designed to be actionable and can guide program adjustments:
- Build the Ladder to the Next In-Field Credential: Creating clear pathways for students to pursue higher credentials within their field can lead to significant gains in earnings.
- Use Certification for Placement and Design for the Second Credential: Encouraging and supporting students in obtaining professional certifications can substantially boost their earning potential. For example, certified medical assistants and dental assistants earn notably more than their non-certified counterparts.
- Paid Work-Based Learning: Incorporating paid internships or other forms of work-based learning can positively impact first-year salaries, with the effect persisting for several years, according to NCES data.
- Place Completers Where the Occupation Pays: Guiding students toward job placements in sectors or settings where their skills are valued more highly can make a difference. Tracking full-time employment status as a key performance indicator is also crucial.
- Add In-Demand Skills: Integrating skills that employers are willing to pay for, such as second-language proficiency, AI skills, or a combination of cognitive and social skills, can increase graduate earnings.
- Do Not Expect Program Length to Help: The analysis found no detectable effect on earnings from increasing program length. Length primarily impacts debt and completion rates, not earning potential for this specific test.
- Manage Scale, Modality, and Classification: Larger programs and those taught primarily online in exposed certificate fields tend to have higher failure rates. Understanding how specific six-digit program codes perform, even within broader four-digit fields, is also important.
For students considering their educational paths, understanding these factors can help in making informed decisions. Exploring programs that actively incorporate certifications, work-based learning, and in-demand skills can lead to better career outcomes. Tools like COSMIQ — free voice AI tutoring, a free voice-driven AI tutor, can also provide valuable support for K-12 and exam-prep learners, helping them build foundational skills that contribute to academic and career success. Additionally, exploring exam prep directories for various certifications can be a proactive step.
A Call to Action for Institutions and Learners
The findings from Validated Insights serve as a critical alert for higher education institutions to proactively assess their program offerings and make necessary adjustments. As Colby notes, "Now is the time to run program numbers and work on at-risk programs. Efforts to support job placement, improved completion rates, and moving students into laddered or increased credential choices can have a measurable effect. Programs are not powerless."
For parents and students, this whitepaper provides valuable context when evaluating college programs. Asking institutions about their graduate employment rates, salary outcomes, and how they support career readiness can help ensure that educational investments lead to meaningful professional opportunities. The emphasis on practical, outcome-driven education continues to grow, and transparency around these metrics is increasingly vital for everyone involved in the higher education ecosystem.
Validated Insights is offering diagnostic reports to institutions, providing detailed benchmarks against state earnings reports. This resource, including the full 81-page report and accompanying case studies, is available for download, empowering institutions to take data-driven action.
Learn anything, free.
COSMIQ is a free, voice-driven AI tutor for every learner. No credit card, ever.
Start learning free →